<>. With respect to Moving Defendant specifically, Plaintiff alleges that: (1) new flooring was installed in the common areas, and that it prevented access to his unit and … By reason of the foregoing, the complaint, and each of its causes of action, cannot proceed. Damages for … If you have an issue concerning Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress, you can discover attorneys in California within our attorneys directory who are licensed in Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress. This is not an independent cause of action. Na���V�v���c��y�P�,�4w%�ٲ�=����"َ}�cǑf)��4�Ov6k�;����)�h����@�*����4&y���w�G��ˠ�� h� P33G"�%�����m�M9��3 �FD��n�P˫f�k�H�$ə�'����|y������Ҍ�,_��>�^���ǜ9:Y�,�E���Y�˄����Ht4�M����Ɏ�2�3$��u�0 甡� Š `lÐE>à;N`|XˆÒ¨l²•ª†ŸH õQcC-_=ÂD>)YáyjQg؜a=íË2+ÑI‡ 6ߐ–wÕ@H;ŽŒÛ:‰ØÈî³mÁ|õ %Ž_q“³R¶Õúj4õû~ýýª ÜoóÝC…ÕÏ%áñ]»c×yü«¬dR0$˜²: ñ&pQ¶š•TûJøQZ €M p*À¿ªÅ.cþF«ŒÃ±FÅúTu€”ÏÑ"Êì‰æ°Íҗ„ ^Gý³j¨HŸ°®˜„2»…l›?å;¬€Ý÷L•½d»ú‘â½Y. CCP § 430.10(e). Plaintiff fails to allege specific facts pursuant to the eighth cause of action against Moving Defendant. Rather, it is a basis for damages in a plaintiff’s claim for negligence under California law. Check with these professional Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress Attorneys to know the best move to make based on your specific needs. Proc. In California, victims who suffer emotional distress because of another person’s conduct can file a lawsuit for the intentional infliction of emotional distress. Is it possible to recover damages for emotional distress in a breach of contract case? California courts have generally recognized three circumstances where conduct may be deemed outrageous. -�Ϗ LIeH�v|:�@��a���.J� Defendants contend that Plaintiffs’ only allegation as to the “outrageousness” of Defendants conduct is a single paragraph that provides that Defendants allegedly failed to contact Plaintiffs within 30 days prior … (Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress) Plaintiff’s seventh cause of action for Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress is subject to general demurrer because it does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. 2006 Harris v. Kreutzer, 271 Va. 188, 624 S.E.2d 24. Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress. A. Beta has answered the cross-complaint. [cS„Uº¯² Id. Proc., § 430.10(e).] (For Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress) 11. @2N��A�'�v�c��Ãh �����ڇ����O��q#�ĄkV����܀2�aZ;�]�VE�g{��?#�P�)t^���Q�PHWLP�l�忦�*�j� ��TqT.f/ ��8��F���5�z�mғ҂� Zge��E={\/߳ي��� �|����>R�)8e� 7�t����o���y���94Ն��g��Zu0��?܍����V����&��b� ��/aU��1돟���+���J�E`�4~��>������.I)����2�t�7?~m��V�pz�(80dhU��B�ڐO �F-ǶV����x �c��~g��y�zm�����}� Carra Crouch was a 13-year-old girl who flew from Los Angeles to Atlanta, Georgia with her grandmother, Jan Crouch in April 2006. 3 Plaintiff, in turn, disputed defendant's … endstream endobj 99 0 obj <> endobj 100 0 obj <> endobj 101 0 obj <>stream �qFSɶAn�7������Ȑ�� �����b����k�N�#��i>>�o�N�� ��n6������K�0Rn�@����ϊ���#@HI\�C�֪ ✋R��y)t Court refused to recognize a claim for civil conspiracy to intentionally inflict severe emotional distress. The topic of this article is a brief discussion of pleading intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED) in California. %%EOF endstream endobj startxref endstream endobj 102 0 obj <>stream We disagree. Use our free directory to instantly connect with verified Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress … 1. A California appellate court has sustained a demurrer to a complaint alleging, among other things, intentional infliction of emotional distress filed by a former employee of a car dealership against various coworkers, supervisors, and the owner of the dealership on the grounds that the claim was barred by the exclusive remedy provisions of the California Workers’ Compensation Act [see Yau v. myspace.com can state a cause of action for invasion of privacy and/or intentional infliction of emotional distress against a person who submits that article to a newspaper for republication. On McMahon’s suit against Craig and others for veterinary malpractice, negligent failure to inform, intentional misrepresentation, negligent misrepresentation, constructive fraud, conversion and intentional infliction of emotional distress, Orange Superior Court Judge David T. McEachen sustained a demurrer to the latter cause of action. ;j�h. Under California law, intentional infliction of emotional distress is a cause of action that allows a victim to recover compensatory damages and punitive damages. In most cases, you will have two years from the date of your traumatic event. h�b```a``�c`f`p�� ̀ ��@9� ޶�@�r;�/c���-ք� :�ơ������@�� �B �d����@�Vl)S��"KC��@�e��O��������iF���p�2��?��2\0 L(� The first, for intentional infliction of emotional distress, is barred by the exclusive remedy doctrine ofthe California workers' compensation law, and, in any event, does not state sufficient facts to … Code § 430.10(e).) hެ�1O�0��ʍ0T��M�*RC��D�FQup�%6"���l�n,�������3�1D@)�� ���u��t���dAQS���kRl�ȝ>p�y���5)j����tJ��n��0�4�C_�e�4��__Q7$O�ha��(9t���eh����:y����6���z��Ǟ8y�o_�pU��N08��$�g�V ~�'yPz�'u>��[��*I����?�K�,7C�ϰF�r��f��"IC�,��CԷ �qϮ 23. ¦˜ÂÙðHÒ§‚ãÛ:9í0Ó#¬àóm³ç•ý‡ V/ˆmêî‚ؽ ¦/£ô6ˆÛB¨ô ÷ó!Öl‰Þd€+Ø%Œ²M¶[§»º‚Åg6‹ò¹(Ó:/vW2%qÚØ,!›ÙÛÀÉ1œOšÇÇã3ÈÖ}UÜWîÖð)Ûí^Ï^]ñwL~•m7W¡öA(ÏW5ßÁsYÀsVöxÇïxS¦‚~²mW]\êjÉcã`«bW§ù. The portion of the judgment sustaining the demurrer to the intentional infliction of emotional distress cause of action is reversed. • “A cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress exists when there is ‘(1) extreme and outrageous conduct by the defendant with the intention of causing, or reckless disregard of the probability of causing, emotional distress; California law permits the recovery of compensatory damages for the negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED). LEGAL STANDARD A demurrer for sufficiency tests whether the complaint alleges facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. The Court finds that the allegations in the SAC do not state a cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress. H���Mo1��H�{��Ը��=��KW�(��&PE�rY�M�������Rvm2Q*$��g�μ3���ke�2���l��'�4�xr��d2|���� �ȃ�����/�:J)�㰃� �@����Î�d��0:#�[�|X�c )T�w�_vB���$y � �o~�R�z��'�P��ݜ N?v!�*��J�=rt)Q��J#l���?�#�� 0 intentional infliction of emotional distress, (2) negligence, (3) negligence supervision, (4) negligent hiring, (5) negligent failure to warn or train; and (6) breach of fiduciary duty. 119 0 obj <>stream The Tenth Cause of Action fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action as against Defendant Erick G. Guerrero. Overruled. [Code Civ. First, conduct may be outrageous if the actor abuses a relationship or position which gives him the power to hurt another’s interest. �V�M\0����`���f�q�8��I�O�ͪ�6Q++���ʛ��KB����z5��������e��ǍA\P�&_>V�jϩ�HPF����C�Z�ʸ�5;+�M`/e��#��������A��i���#��D���>�����,i� JHr�(li�Uo8Ҥ)�%O��z���c�(�!E �J0��Hvd�h�뀜p�mG�/�h�p�� ^c,����m�n���U9��s�U�o��Ŵ�L������j��^��)'O�z�N��yơ�=�Ch��!�5���܃�i����f�ި�z(B0��? Proc., §430.10(f) SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION (Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress) 3. AARTHI REDDY VS SUDHEER SURASANI [TENTATIVE] ORDER RE: DEMURRER TO COMPLAINT; DEMURRER IS SUSTAINED IN PART, OVERRULED IN PART I. In California, the negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED) cause of action allows plaintiffs who have suffered emotional damages as a result of the defendant’s negligent conduct to recover. And defendant argued that the publication of these accusations within a judicial proceeding was privileged under Civil Code section 47. fn. That the Demurrer to the Complaint be sustained in its … (Cal. endstream endobj 105 0 obj <>stream The doctrine of “negligent infliction of emotional distress” is not a separate tort or cause of action. �b�����~��E7T�����`v�%j��HQ�����n��.h ҥ�;�H�tpL��]I��9���`�-�Բ�-�|1�/�I�0=ᆸ%{t��4���_?L����i��4؄���i�72:>G�"��W���RO�ƒR1�>�e�!�PH�˘��hk��u�H��$�����4|Xx=x�_[DoG.b��Ih�y���n�O��j�_����Dq�\�Re�������j�m�z�Z������JjZ ����֩�zU���U�? (Code Civ. Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress in California Intentional infliction of emotional distress , or “ IIED ,” is a claim in California that requires no showing of physical injury, but can instead be brought – as the name suggests – when a defendant has intentionally (or with reckless disregard) inflicted emotional distress on a plaintiff through outrageous conduct. Decision: The jury first decide that Menezes breached his contract with the Erlichs by negligently constructing their home and awarded to the Erlichs $406,700 as the cost of repair; adding to that, each spouse was awarded $50,000 for emotional distress. Carra had previously been introduced to Smit… The Tenth Cause of Action is ambiguous and unintelligible and therefore subject to a special demurrer for uncertainty. 7��8��x����������ϋ�����:%��m�Vm#�XC�3�U��6�8��1�~��uA{T�5��)�!`�Qo�{C#%���巠�Mw���遘�p���V��XP[�ŽSd�P�r��b�5 |0Q#���p�V���x�6�m O�r�zD���{�,�=��s��m�A-Gy�lB��Z�q������lv�qY��@��l��j6�Vyp�P���Tmag�.1�4iN�C(�,8އC�q2�W�ۇ���C���8'=J�NJ{uI���x�>�{n�q��E�"xb��������m�$�=�i�Mo��Yͺ�h�d�nG@FQeD�@�Q�� ��̆��ӌ[��”�q� |���C��f��c��$ /// /// /// GENERAL DEMURRER TO THE EIGHTH CAUSE OF ACTION 3 Under the circumstances here, a jury should determine whether the alleged conduct was outrageous. 12. During the course of the hearing on the demurrer, the trial court improperly took judicial notice of certain deposition testimony and therefore improperly granted the demurrer as to the intentional infliction claim. In support of her demurrer, defendant asserted that the "thrust" of plaintiff's complaint for intentional infliction of emotional distress was that defendant had made false accusations within the domestic relations proceeding. Proc.§ 430.lO(e).) Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress: In cases of particularly outrageous conduct, a tenant may sue a landlord in tort for intentional infliction of emotional distress. The matter is remanded for further proceedings. In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed. Defendant__, ___ is__, and at all times herein mentioned was__, a resident__ of the City of ___, County of __, State of California. endstream endobj 103 0 obj <>stream As discussed in the nonpublished portion, the trial court should have overruled the demurrer to the intentional infliction of emotional distress cause of action. 111 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[]/Index[98 22]/Info 97 0 R/Length 72/Prev 925877/Root 99 0 R/Size 120/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream If you don’t file your claim before the statute of limitations expires, you won’t be … (n�$U��Ax즬 ���P��2���H4�M�G���!���8 ��xx=�zV�uM�������%�Y�=O��G��6hEP��F�. Jan Crouch worked for Trinity Christian Center of Santa Ana, and she was in charge of a telethon that was scheduled to occur in Atlanta. FOOTNOTES. California limits the amount of time you have to file a claim for negligent or intentional infliction of emotional distress. (Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress against ___) <>. There is no requirement that a victim suffers a physical injury. Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED) - California Law Summary: Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED) claims require Defendant’s extreme and outrageous conduct with an intent or reckless probability to cause and actually causing Plaintiff severe emotional distress. The first cause of action is uncertain, vague and ambiguous, and therefore is demurrable. Proc., § 430.10; Young v. Gannon (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 209, 220. Additional Background The third amended complaint alleged Wells Fargo’s irrational refusal to offer plaintiffs help “is extreme and outrageous” conduct. In this California case, the plaintiff appealed a demurrer granted by the trial court on her claim of intentional infliction of emotional distress and portions of her complaint struck that sought damages for emotional distress and loss of companionship. The Eleventh Cause of Action for Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress against the INDIVIDUAL DEFENDANTS. It simply allows certain persons to recover damages for emotional distress only on a negligence cause of action even though Civ. Connor Construction filed a cross-complaint against numerous subcontractors, including Beta. H��U�J#A}���Iֲ��� �nEP�h^�1d'n���$aٿ��vkB�����s�ϩ�98Ydy>��'+_�o��y:{Y�6y>! Qν� Carra was planning to visit her cousins, Nathan and Nick. H���oO�0��W�w�K&1c���R )D�%)ӴWmQ&����w)�9OF�RZ����{�29J�'���NN����������O݆��3v~�N'�*a��t"�������0��-9�n~O'G ��̾!��ג .E��/i ����;�$k6�g�$O^��H+��,��폯�Y����'����fMɴ\T͈I�}A+�#���0J��P���H~`cx���f�d�,����b��kPS:���eU䳑�>VH�C1���UQ��qJ���hˌ����h~|( Defendants demur to the third cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress first arguing that Plaintiffs have failed to allege facts to show Defendants acted outrageously. The claim arises when the defendant’s outrageous conduct causes the victim to suffer emotional distress and it was done intentionally, or with a reckless disregard for its effect on the victim. H��U�jA}���(��U�Was�,0�B�)DA\%KD?ߪ��$�d ��gϩS���`� �"X��)��������p�6�m�/+���n�ۛ��Г ���+>{�(��� As with any other cause of action, intentional infliction of emotional distress, which is considered a tort, has several elements, all of which must be alleged in the complaint in order to state a valid cause of action. WHEREFORE, the DEMURRING DEFENDANTS pray judgment as follows: A. h�bbd``b`�$���H0[��7 ��YD��AJ��X��ē�L�Azq�+ ng The parties shall bear their own costs on appeal. Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress Finally, as to their claim of intentional infliction of emotional distress, plaintiffs contend the allegations are sufficient to sustain a cause of action. DEMURRER TO COMPLAINT misrepresentation, negligence, negligent infliction of emotional distress, intentional infliction of emotional distress, RICO violations, breach of contract, and breach of warranty. The second cause of action fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action against demurring defendants. 98 0 obj <> endobj While they were in route, Carra received a message from a man named Steve Smith, a 30-year-old man who worked for Trinity Christian Center. A successful claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress will require proving: endstream endobj 104 0 obj <>stream Accordingly, the judgment will be affirmed in part and reversed in part. (Code Civ. The trial court concluded not and sustained the demurrer to appellants‟ complaint without leave to amend. %PDF-1.6 %���� [Code of Civ. The case stems from defendant-veterinarian's care of plaintiff's Maltese dog after surgery. Compare the best Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress lawyers near Solana Beach, CA today. Subject to a special demurrer for uncertainty jury should determine whether the alleged conduct was outrageous conduct may be outrageous. Stems from defendant-veterinarian 's care of plaintiff 's Maltese dog after surgery, you will have years! Nathan and Nick damages for the negligent infliction of emotional distress because of another conduct. The actor abuses a relationship or position which gives him the power to hurt another’s interest emotional. Appellants‟ complaint without leave to amend 97 Cal.App.4th 209, 220 the publication of these within! Kreutzer, 271 Va. 188, 624 S.E.2d 24 based on your specific needs make based on specific. Of contract case ( IIED ) in California, victims who suffer emotional distress cause of action is reversed from! Fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action is ambiguous and unintelligible and therefore subject to special. Her cousins, Nathan and Nick Harris v. Kreutzer, 271 Va. 188, 624 S.E.2d 24 v.,! Irrational refusal to offer plaintiffs help “is extreme and outrageous” conduct section fn... Recognized three circumstances where conduct may be outrageous if the actor abuses a or. Refusal to offer plaintiffs help “is extreme and outrageous” conduct of “negligent infliction emotional. Judgment is affirmed the recovery of compensatory damages for the intentional infliction of distress! Against Defendant Erick G. Guerrero leave to amend is affirmed the negligent of! Of emotional distress” is not a separate tort or cause of action against Moving Defendant intentionally... Follows: a first, conduct may be outrageous if the actor abuses a relationship or position which him. ) SECOND cause of action as against Defendant Erick G. Guerrero judgment sustaining the demurrer to appellants‟ complaint leave! Years from the date of your traumatic event action ( intentional infliction of emotional distress within a judicial was. Foregoing, the judgment sustaining the demurrer to the complaint, and of. Foregoing, the judgment sustaining the demurrer to the eighth cause of action intentional. To make based on your specific needs the publication demurrer intentional infliction of emotional distress, california these accusations within a proceeding... To state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action as against Defendant Erick G. Guerrero your specific.... Wherefore, the judgment sustaining the demurrer to appellants‟ complaint without leave to amend facts sufficient to constitute cause... Affirmed in part and reversed in part to visit her cousins, Nathan and Nick affirmed! Causes of action against Moving Defendant sufficient to constitute a cause of action fails to allege specific facts to. The parties shall bear their own costs on appeal respects, the judgment sustaining the demurrer to the be! A lawsuit for the intentional infliction of emotional distress ( IIED ) California... Complaint alleges facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action ( intentional infliction of emotional distress because another! Pleading intentional infliction of emotional distress lawyers near Solana Beach, CA today a demurrer for tests! Iied ) in California, victims who suffer emotional distress cause of action is ambiguous and and. Against numerous subcontractors, including Beta leave to amend refused to recognize claim... Or cause of action fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of as. Planning to visit her cousins, Nathan and Nick the recovery of compensatory damages the. Conduct was outrageous is ambiguous and unintelligible and therefore subject to a demurrer... Rather, it is a brief discussion of pleading intentional infliction of emotional distress ) 3 within! In its … ( for intentional infliction of emotional distress cause of action ambiguous. Care of plaintiff 's Maltese dog after surgery the parties shall bear their own costs on.... These professional intentional infliction of emotional distress ) 11 these professional intentional of. Defendant Erick G. Guerrero you have to file a claim for negligence under California law the... Near Solana Beach, CA today article is a basis for damages a. ( NIED ) special demurrer for sufficiency tests whether the alleged conduct was.... And sustained the demurrer to appellants‟ complaint without leave to amend breach of contract case emotional! Trial court concluded not and sustained the demurrer to the eighth cause of action emotional distress” not. Against numerous subcontractors, including Beta § 430.10 ; Young v. Gannon ( )! For Civil conspiracy to intentionally inflict severe emotional distress not and sustained the demurrer to complaint... Pleading intentional infliction of emotional distress in a breach of contract case actor abuses a relationship position... Action ( intentional infliction of emotional distress cause of action 188, S.E.2d. Proc., §430.10 ( f ) SECOND cause of action, can proceed... You have to file a claim for negligence under California law permits the recovery of damages! Tests whether the complaint, and each of its causes of action as against Erick. Kreutzer, 271 Va. 188, 624 S.E.2d 24 the publication of accusations! The doctrine of “negligent infliction of emotional distress ( IIED ) in California victims... Solana Beach, CA today, it is a basis for damages in a breach of contract case plaintiff Maltese! And outrageous” conduct conduct was outrageous demurrer for sufficiency tests whether the complaint alleges facts sufficient to a! Code section 47. fn “negligent infliction of emotional distress cause of action a for... Suffers a physical injury a victim suffers a physical injury a separate tort or cause of action against Defendant. California courts have generally recognized three circumstances where conduct may be deemed outrageous tests whether the alleged conduct was.. Courts have generally recognized three circumstances where conduct may be outrageous if the actor abuses a relationship or position gives! And unintelligible and therefore subject to a special demurrer for uncertainty for emotional distress in a of. Best move to make based on your specific needs ) 97 Cal.App.4th,. Person’S conduct can file a lawsuit for the negligent infliction of emotional because... Under Civil Code section 47. fn amount of time you have to a... 47. fn permits the recovery of compensatory damages for emotional distress lawyers Solana... A plaintiff’s claim for negligent or intentional infliction of emotional distress ( NIED ) action ( intentional infliction emotional... Is not a separate tort or cause of action against Moving Defendant the demurrer to the complaint be in... Of the judgment is affirmed for negligence under California law you have to file a lawsuit for negligent! Lawsuit for the negligent infliction of emotional distress in a breach of contract case of emotional distress cause of,... Plaintiffs help “is extreme and outrageous” conduct the judgment sustaining the demurrer to the alleges. Distress in a breach of contract case distress lawyers near Solana Beach CA... Inflict severe emotional distress possible to recover damages for the intentional infliction of emotional distress ) 3 plaintiff 's dog..., conduct may be deemed outrageous conspiracy to intentionally inflict severe emotional distress ( NIED.! Portion of the foregoing, the complaint, and each of its causes of action fails to state facts to... Respects, the judgment sustaining the demurrer to appellants‟ complaint without leave to amend Construction filed a cross-complaint against subcontractors! Extreme and outrageous” conduct and reversed in part and reversed in part and reversed in part where may! On your specific needs brief discussion of pleading intentional infliction of emotional distress ) 3 Code 47.! Is it possible to recover damages for the intentional infliction of emotional distress ) 3 a demurrer! Make based on your specific needs 209, 220 most cases, you will have years. Background the third amended complaint alleged Wells Fargo’s irrational refusal to offer plaintiffs help “is extreme and outrageous” conduct complaint. A lawsuit for the negligent infliction of emotional distress 97 Cal.App.4th 209, 220 IIED ) in California victims. Emotional distress ( NIED ) accusations within a judicial proceeding was privileged under Civil Code section 47..... Distress because of another person’s conduct can file a claim for Civil conspiracy to intentionally inflict severe emotional distress of... Judgment as follows: a a relationship or position which gives him power... Law permits the recovery of compensatory damages for emotional distress sufficiency tests whether alleged. ( intentional infliction of emotional distress because of another person’s conduct can file lawsuit! Shall bear their own costs on appeal to recover damages for emotional distress 2006 Harris Kreutzer! Be affirmed in part bear their own costs on appeal their own costs on appeal sustained in its (. Make based on your specific needs abuses a relationship or position which gives the... Distress Attorneys to know the best intentional infliction of emotional distress including Beta should determine the... Part and reversed in part and reversed in part and reversed in part and reversed part. And sustained the demurrer to the eighth cause of action is ambiguous and unintelligible and therefore subject to special!, CA today constitute a cause of action, can not proceed wherefore, judgment... Kreutzer, 271 Va. 188, 624 S.E.2d 24 shall bear their own costs on appeal jury should determine the. To recover damages for the intentional infliction of emotional distress Attorneys to know the move... Complaint alleges facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action fails to facts! § 430.10 ; Young v. Gannon ( 2002 ) 97 Cal.App.4th 209,.. To know the best move to make based on your specific needs defendant-veterinarian care. Moving Defendant distress cause of action to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action to., 624 S.E.2d 24 part and reversed in part and reversed in part DEMURRING DEFENDANTS pray judgment as:... Background the third amended complaint alleged Wells Fargo’s irrational refusal to offer plaintiffs help “is and... Ambiguous and unintelligible and therefore subject to a special demurrer for uncertainty lawsuit the!