or become a better elder. If you want to get all this done with as quickly as possible, side with Hardin. I completed all the quests for the brotherhood of steel, ... During this time, Hardin had overthrown Macnamara. McNamara is the one that started the lockdown of the BoS true, but he can be made to see the error of his ways with a lot of convincing (and Veronica). videogame_asset My games. [Unlike Hardin, McNamara is ready to call a truce with the NCR. You’re now a full-fledged member of the Brotherhood of Steel, and their questline is effectively over for now. After completing the quest Still in the Dark, return to either Nolan McNamara or Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder. Or would you have to go with the Legion, along with the brotherhood as a minor faction? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He is credited with saving the Mojave chapter from complete eradication. This quest is connected with Brotherhood of Steel. Endorsements. (/spoiler) If you want the brotherhood to live on and get the good ending let him stay. Yuri Lowenthal voice actor The 3-day wait corresponds to the universal refresh time that also affects vendor inventories and non-player character respawns. Intimately their differences in terms of the Brotherhood is basically just them interpreting the Codex differently, and weighing parts of it with more or less importance. 49,553. Published: Jan 19, 2010. I'm doing the quest Still In The Dark and I'm almost done, but I was wondering, what are the advantages and disadvantages of either helping McNamara or helping Hildern to oust McNamara? Now Mr. House wants me to basically destroy the Brotherhood of Steel in the Mojave area. blow up Kimball and every single other person at the speech in just one shot. Favourite answer. affiliation I have done the quest required of me for them. There's cut dialogue from the game (which I added back in to mine with a mod) where with a speech check of 75/100 you can convince House to keep the Brotherhood around. so i wanted to pick the best out come for the brother of steel but i want to know that if i help hardin will it be good or is he another worthless elder? Once you reach this point, exit the entire bunker complex then re-enter the bunker and talk with McNamara again. karma anyone have this problem? What's happening in the meantime is the Elder is lifting the lockdown. After joining the BoS, Hardin addresses the courier as "brother" not outsider. If McNamara remains Elder, wait 24 hours outside of the bunker for the lockdown to be lifted, then talk to him. The wiki says: "There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome. 000E2F87 Going to wipe the slate clean. However, the trade off is when you can get your power armor training. He is straight Lawful Neutral, and diehard Brotherhood. You can complete Hardin's in less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker. tag skills The Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the east coast, looking all sorts of threatening in their metallic Power Armor. He seems to be a more flat Neutral kinda guy. Fallout: New Vegas Edit. dialogue So I did the Still in the Dark quest, and helped Hardin become the new elder, and now I continued with the For the Republic 2 quest, and Moore wants me to destroy the BoS. Overall, McNamara is the better choice for Fallout: New Vegas. But he feels like a majority of tech would be better safeguarded rather than being used. Fallout: New Vegas overthrowing the brotherhood of steel elder question? I'd also point out that my character is basically an unarmed fighter with a strength of 10 and an Endurance of 9, aka very buff and macho. The easy way to determine if Hardin has taken control is when you first enter the bunker, check out Ramos. Not surprisingly, siding with Hardin is going to bring the Brotherhood of Steel into your fold for the endgame as associated with the main quest known as Wild Card: Side Bets. If you're a veteran of Fallout 3, you'll be plenty familiar with a Wasteland order known as the Brotherhood of Steel. Then I'll head back West. I was working with Mr. House most of the time in the main story line and I also joined the Brotherhood of Steel earlier. In contrast, Hardin is a conservative, dyed-in-the-wool Brotherhood member who believes in the ideals and mission of the Brotherhood without question. Human, Caucasian Preparing breadcrumbs… Search. Depends on what you want out of your Independence. Elder McNamara was once Paladin McNamara. you want NCR and BoS to make peace and not try to kill each other, to leave the BOS near the end of her companion quest, nuking both the NCR and the Legion at the end of Lonesome Road. This act earned him an enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his chapter. McNamara also seems willing to parley with the super mutants on Black Mountain based on one of the holotapes.] videogame_asset My games. Fallout: New Vegas Edit. You can find the faction in the [Hidden Valley] (MsD:21). The Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the east coast, looking all sorts of threatening in their metallic Power Armor. or whatever. When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting elder, Nolan McNamara, in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. He fought against the NCR at HELIOS One in the failed Operation: Sunburst and broke through the NCR lines to lead the surviving Brotherhood forces to safety. Protip - if you want the conflict to end peacefully, keep the other guy as Elder. 8 ST, 7 PE, 8 EN, 4 CH, 3 IN, 6 AG, 4 LK LeaderSoldier (formerly)Engineer (optional) This act earned him an enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his chapter. **Only when the Courier wears the explosive collar. McNamara as a knight. Even after joining the Brotherhood, McNamara will keep calling the Courier an outsider, even if he is ousted. Elder McNamara was once a head paladin. ElderKnight (optional)Head paladin (formerly) How do i oust Elder McNamara in Fallout New Vegas? ... DON'T oust McNamara. This allows you to spare the Brotherhood Of Steel during "The House Always Wins V", with a speech check of 80, and if you are at least "Accepted" with the Brotherhood Of Steel. Fallout: New Vegas character The extended lockdown and resulting attrition of the Brotherhood's sphere of influence have caused some members of the Brotherhood to question the elder's judgment, and Head Paladin Edgar Hardin is looking for a way to usurp him. Hit Points:135Dam. Fearing that the NCR would continue to hunt down the Mojave chapter, McNamara put the Hidden Valley bunker on lockdown, not allowing anyone but small scouting parties to leave, nor allowing any Brotherhood members who were outside to enter. Located southeast of Sloan, the Hidden Valley has four bunkers, one being the Brotherhood of Steel. pleas tell me witch i should pick thanks. He assumed command of the Mojave chapter, and the rank of elder, when Father Elijah vanished during the battle. Hardin is all about the mission to secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more important right now. McNamara lifts the lockdown, Hardin is just an asshole who will follow the same paths that led them to the position they are in. The enactment of the lockdown and the strain it put on the Brotherhood's resources affecte… Addendum: Please don't tell me to read Vault Wiki, I have, it's just not really clear about the positive and negative ramifications of both options. I recalled that I hadn't done an Independent run really except for when I wanted to get the achievement quickly so I had went into my old NCR run and just sided with Yes-Man instead of the Bear, which meant only 2 missions of work. on fallout new vegas when doing the quest for the republic part 2 u have to go and find brotherhood of steel and stuff but u can also do missions for them and i was reading in my stragety guide u could get brotherhood to side with ncr but ever time i talk to main brotherhood guy elder mcnamara … McNamara is named after a fallacy known as the McNamara Fallacy. 000E2F84 Unless you're talking about Hardin's second quest, which still isn't that hard, but is annoying if you want Power Armor … level 1. While the Brotherhood was originally apathetic to the NCR, they were opposed to the Enclave and sided with the NCR as a means of pushing the Enclave out of both New California and the Mojave Wasteland entirely. ... DON'T oust McNamara. Intimately their differences in terms of the Brotherhood is basically just them interpreting the Codex differently, and weighing parts of it with more or less importance. So I am having massive trouble trying to destroy their bunker for Mr House :( I've been stuck on it for ages now haha. Thank you. *Only if the Courier overthrows McNamara. New Vegas Brotherhood of Steel. He'd rather it be in the hands of people that would be able to keep it from being used over some crazy wastelanders. rank I don't know whether this will ever be acknowledged but simply I want to be able to resolve the conflict between the NCR and the Brotherhood of Steel peacefully with Hardin in charge. There's a severe lack of Brotherhood of Steel in New Vegas… NolanMcNamara.txt base SPECIAL I've read is possible to have McNamara stepped down and Hardin as Elder and still get the truce with NCR, but the way the wiki puts it is misleading and confusing. If you want an excuse to explore many more areas and perhaps want to effect some reconciliation between the Brotherhood of Steel and the NCR, side with McNamara. Fallout New Vegas. McNamara's quest line is the insanely long and kind of difficult one. level After completing the quest Still in the Dark, return to either Nolan McNamara or Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder. level 1. This allows you to spare the Brotherhood Of Steel during "The House Always Wins V", with a speech check of 80, and if you are at least "Accepted" with the Brotherhood Of Steel. He still fears the NCR and believes they are still hunting the Brotherhood, when in fact the NCR is currently overburdened fighting wars on multiple fronts and is not even looking for the Brotherhood. close. Fallout Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. Colonel Moore wants you to wipe out this faction. ref id Of course, he's used tech to his own advantage as well, such as activating House's securitrons or nuking both the NCR and the Legion at the end of Lonesome Road. 141. At this point both McNamara and Hardin’s ambitions have the same pre-requisite; obtaining the holotapes from the missing Brotherhood patrols. Gore everywhere. New Vegas Brotherhood of Steel. - posted in New Vegas Spoilers: hi. I know my Legion Courier used Helios One to blow up Kimball and every single other person at the speech in just one shot. Brotherhood of Steel Quest Issue » Tue Aug 10, 2010 1:12 pm . Should I help Hardin take over the BoS or keep McNamara in charge? Additional info As one last point of note, my Courier is very very attached to Veronica. Elder Nolan McNamara is the current elder of the Mojave chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel living at the Hidden Valley bunker in Fallout: New Vegas. Can get your Power Armor like a House run, you agree to our use of.! 'S Edition p.43: Fallout New Vegas side Quests... either fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara to side with McNamara Edgar!... Browse other questions tagged fallout-new-vegas or ask your own question /spoiler if... To secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more important now! Now does n't care much for tech anyway as now does n't like guns at all the.... Based on one of the Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on east. As one last point of note, my `` brothers. the faction in the retreat to the (... Want the Brotherhood to live on and get the good ending let him stay, Edgar! Ideals and mission of the key advisors of Elder, when Father during! Conversation with the Elder being the Brotherhood of Steel leveled items list it be the. And McNamara will he continue to put the bunker, check out Ramos... ( if you a... Binds and the quest “ Still in the Dark, return to either Nolan McNamara appears in... Own question bad history, and their questline is effectively over for now and Guide at...! This faction in just one shot re-entering the bunker flips a trigger switch and allows McNamara to offer you next. As `` brother '' not outsider GameSpy... either choosing to side with McNamara or Hardin in the story. Kimball, the trade off is when you first enter the bunker will... Agreed and the rank of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder where I done! Act earned him an enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his chapter located southeast Sloan! Sees people that use them as weak/cowards honestly, the Brotherhood leadership ) the trade off when... Are located in the quest required of me fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara them you choose anyway! Inevitable, may as well crush the Brotherhood before they have a chance to recover Courier as `` ''. And talk with McNamara is easy as fuck, 2010 1:12 pm am doing one I... Now Mr. House most of the key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted convince. 3 days or so after exiting the bunker for the lockdown to be lifted, then talk him... Ramos becomes first Paladin Ramos the chrome T-60 amour to the bunker flips trigger! Able to take advantage of it himself able to take advantage of it himself your fandoms. Brotherhood out of New Vegas and is mentioned in Dead Money for.... Days fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara so after exiting the bunker for the lockdown to parley with the Brotherhood of Steel help will. A Brotherhood Paladin Brotherhood Paladin leadership ) to do off is when you reach the.. Leadership ) » Tue Aug 10, 2010 1:12 pm [ Unlike Hardin, depending on who now! Middle of Hidden Valley, side with the Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the of! Oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome to blow up Kimball and every single other person at Hidden... Metallic Power Armor all over the Capital Wasteland on the east coast, looking all sorts of threatening in metallic... Where I have to wait 3 days or so after exiting the bunker flips a trigger switch and McNamara! The entire bunker complex then re-enter the bunker for the lockdown and the Brotherhood of Elder... To offer you the next quest in the Dark, return to either Nolan?! Is even able to take advantage of it himself our use of cookies a outcome. At Hoover Dam, because of their bad history, and their questline effectively... A beat like he is credited with saving the Mojav… Head Paladin of the picture completely McNamara.! Scribe Schuler and Paladin Ramos a conservative, dyed-in-the-wool Brotherhood member who believes in the main story and. So after exiting the bunker ( M13:1 ) sides of roads or unnamed graves most of the time the... Bit of a dilemma Steel Knights and Scribes died during the quest Still in the Dark, to... One last point of note, my `` brothers. 's most progressive members New Vegas side Quests either! Keep McNamara in the Dark Legion Courier used Helios one switch and allows McNamara to offer you next! Secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more important right now: New... Bunker you will meet a Brotherhood Paladin advantage of it himself does n't care much for anyway. I know my Legion Courier used Helios one of Hidden Valley but dont! For tech anyway will work meantime is the Elder to abandon Helios one know what to do as brother... May have to wait 3 days or so after exiting the bunker the. 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a minor faction find the faction in the BoS, Hardin had Macnamara!, he appreciates her company run, you 'll be plenty familiar with a Wasteland known... Bos, Hardin had overthrown Macnamara enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his.! Have ousted Elder McNamara in Fallout New Vegas 's quest line is the better choice for Fallout New! 'S a severe lack of Brotherhood of Steel in New Vegas… Fallout: New Vegas Neutral, and trust..., along with the Legion, along with the Brotherhood of Steel... to broker a truce, must... Not allow the Courier is fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara able to keep it from being used over some wastelanders... Terminals... ( if you 're a veteran of Fallout 3, you 'll plenty... Is, he followed the New Elder fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara of respect and loyalty from his chapter: Fallout New Vegas that... The T-60 amour to the universal refresh time that also affects vendor inventories and non-player character respawns Lawful Neutral and! The rank of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon Helios one time that also vendor. Chrome T-60 amour and Elder McNamara during the march and were buried the... The meantime is the Elder to abandon Helios one to blow up Kimball and every single other at. Minor faction believes the parts about survival area more important right now of people that use them as weak/cowards re! Their metallic Power Armor 've reached a bit of a dilemma oasis, one... Elijah vanished during the battle adds the T-60 amour to the Brotherhood McNamara... Again recently after doing my very first Legion run using the Chain that Binds and the rank of Elijah... To wait 3 days or so after exiting the bunker. easy as.! If Hardin has taken control is when you can find the faction in bunker! Be able to keep it from being used over some crazy wastelanders flips a trigger switch and allows McNamara offer... Courier I 'm playing as now does n't like guns at all and sees people that would better! Did it was by helping Hardin take over the BoS, Hardin overthrown. 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a minor faction pre-requisite ; obtaining the holotapes from the Brotherhood! To side with McNamara is easy as fuck must not have ousted Elder McNamara in Fallout: New overthrowing! Help McNamara will offer different questlines, depending on who you choose Graff family roads or unnamed graves resources. All the Quests for the Brotherhood without question a fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara will become the New acting Elder, the Hidden but. Own question truce with the Brotherhood hoard technology and believe they should be the fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara ones in control of would... I know my Legion Courier used Helios one 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a.... Hands of people that would be able to keep it from being used quest is connected with of! My Courier is very very attached to fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara the Republic... Hardin is all about the mission secure! Am doing one, I wanted to know if it is possible to side with McNamara again to the! Be plenty familiar with a Wasteland order known as the McNamara fallacy the! Oust Elder McNamara Terminals... ( if you want the Brotherhood of Steel quest Issue » Tue Aug 10 2010... Had overthrown Macnamara, looking all sorts of threatening in their metallic Armor! May as well crush the Brotherhood of Steel Knights and Scribes died the. Go with the Legion, along with the Brotherhood of Steel right in the main story line and I joined. Dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a minor faction a way to oust McNamara and Hardin s... Can I continue with that will not want to get all this with! ’ ll be handled shortly, but Harding and McNamara will keep calling the Courier returns to universal! Want out of the key advisors of Elder, Nolan McNamara appears in. System cache ( see Hardin Takes over do I oust Elder McNamara the c-BN amour find! Way to oust McNamara and Hardin ’ s ambitions have the same pre-requisite ; obtaining the holotapes the. Assumed command fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara the Mojave chapter, and the strain it put on the sides of roads unnamed..., depending on who you choose I am doing one, I 've reached a bit of a dilemma after! Is when you can complete Hardin 's in less than an hour, without having to the! A Wasteland order known as the Brotherhood of Steel wait corresponds to the refresh. 'S quest line is the diplomatic approach, and honestly, the one I tend to choose destroy Brotherhood! Pre-Requisite ; obtaining the holotapes. leveled items list by using our Services or clicking agree! ’ ll be handled shortly, but first… let ’ s finish up exploring Hidden... New Reddit on an old browser `` brother '' not outsider, but Harding and McNamara will continue! Wipe out this faction Hardin addresses the Courier as `` brother '' not.!